AG’s Investigation Into Catholic Church Could Result In More Than 1000 Victims And Take Two Years

Feb 22, 2019

Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel
Credit Cheyna Roth / MPRN

It started last October.  More than 70 police officers, special agents, and government officials executed search warrants on each of the seven Catholic dioceses in Michigan simultaneously.  They loaded vehicles with boxes and filing cabinets – everything they could find related to potential sexual abuse by priests who have worked in Michigan from 1950 until now.  Attorney General Dana Nessel says Michigan is the first state to execute a search warrant on the Church in this way.  Now, Nessel says she expects her office’s investigation to last at least two years.   

Hundreds of thousands of documents were seized during the raids, and an investigative team is reviewing more than 300 tips already received. 

Attorney General Dana Nessel was slim on details about the investigation since it is ongoing.  But Michigan State Police Colonel Joe Gasper says not all dioceses are being as cooperative as investigators would like. 

"I think that the level of cooperation…it varies.  But what’s important is that from a standpoint of the investigation that the two agencies are undergoing it’s important  that that take priority over any parallel investigation."

When Gasper says “parallel investigation,” he’s talking about the dioceses that have conducted their own reviews into priests suspected of abuse.

Nessel wants all the dioceses to stop doing that.  And she says if a church official is trying to conduct its own investigation, people should not cooperate.  

"And what I would like to say to the public is this: If an investigator comes to your door and asks to speak with you, please ask to see their badge and not their rosary. "

The Catholic Church has a long history of trying to handle abuse allegations “in-house,” and victims are often reluctant to come forward.

Bishop Thomas Gumbleton works with the group, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, or SNAP.  He says he was forced to retire from his post as the auxiliary bishop of the Detroit archdiocese after he publicly discussed being sexually abused during his time in seminary as a teenager.  Gumbleton says he’s hopeful that things are different now, and that the Church will cooperate with Nessel’s investigation.

"We’re still human beings, and so we’re probably not going to be perfect, but we have to do the very best we can to come as close to eliminating the problem totally as we can do it."

But others aren’t so sure.

Jason Negri is the co-founder of the Daniel Coalition.  That’s a group of lay Catholics in Lansing.

Negri says many predators within the Catholic Church have been rooted out, but not all.  And an investigation like Nessel’s is necessary, in part, because some officials within the Catholic Church are still reluctant to expose predators.

"Predatory priests are harming people.  Men, women and children.  They need to get out now, and if the bishops won’t do it voluntarily, they’re going to be made to do it."

The Catholic Diocese of Lansing says it welcomes Nessel’s review, and it says it does not know of any active members who have abused children.

Other dioceses have issued statements saying they will cooperate with Nessel’s investigation.

Still, Nessel has a very strong message for predator priests and anyone who attempts to cover up abuse.

"I don’t care how old they are, I don’t care where they live, all I care about is whether or not they committed a crime.  And if they did and it’s within the statute of limitations and if we have the evidence to prove it, they’re going to get charged."

Nessel encourages anyone who wants to report clergy abuse to contact her office.

Non-commercial, fact based reporting is made possible by your financial support.  Make your donation to WEMU today to keep your community NPR station thriving.

Like 89.1 WEMU on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

—Cheyna Roth is a reporter for the Michigan Public Radio network.  Contact WEMU News at 734.487.3363 or email us at